Academia or Industry?

That question seems to be on the mind of a lot of the people around me lately. Junior year of my undergrad studies at Brown is almost over, and my classmates and I are starting to think of what our lives will be like after next May. For people interested in the sciences, especially biology and biotech related fields. there are two main options everyone considers: should I get a job right our of undergrad, with only a bachelor’s degree? Or, should I stay in school for another 5+ years for a Ph.D?  There are obvious benefits and costs to each (which I’ll cover in a later post), and everyone wants to know exactly what choice will be best for them.

Up until recently, I have wanted to go to graduate school the fall after finishing at Brown. I feel like I’m ready for what the process entails, thanks in part to the books I’ve been reading by recent (either delighted or regretful) Ph.D recipients. But now, I’m not so sure. The Brown Club of Boston Biotech Conference was a big factor in this – listing to people in industry talk about the opportunities for bachelor’s degree holders was eye opening. The starting salaries they mentioned were impressive (and not much less than what you’d get as a Ph.D). The projects looked interesting.  And most importantly, the jobs are there.

I’m considering taking a year or two to work in industry before committing to grad school. After all, whats a year delay when you’re going to be in school for another 5-7 ?

Books on Graduate School

Students are pretty much on their own for figuring things out after undergrad (I definitely don’t miss high school guidance counselors, though). Grad school is a confusing topic – I find that everyone talks about it, but some people don’t really know what to expect if they commit the next 5 years of their life to getting another degree. Asking students in your lab, professors and graduating seniors is a great way to get information, but it’s still hard to get a good picture of what the whole process is like. Over winter break this year I found a few good books that summarize what you can expect at a graduate program in the sciences.

  • The Ph.D Grind by Philip Guo
    This short memoir details Philip’s time at Stanford from 2006 to 2012 while he worked toward a Ph.D in computer science. His story is filled with countless ups and downs, tips to get work published and lessons about working efficiently and maintaining sanity during stressful times. It’s a free ebook, quick read, and definitely recommended (even if you’re not considering computer science).
  • Getting What You Came For by Robert Peters
    The second edition of this book was published in 1992 so it’s a little outdated (it references word processors like they’re the next big thing, for example). It is still a good general account of the entire graduate school process, though. Getting What You Came For covers everything you should be doing in undergrad, how to pick a graduate school that’s a good fit for you, how to navigate your first years in the program while finding an advisor and taking quals, how to get the thesis done, and much more. It’s definitely not a quick read, but I’m keeping a copy for reference.
  • The Ph.D Process by Dale Bloom, Jonathan Karp and Nicholas Cohen
    Another book that lays out each step in the process of getting a Ph.D. Kind of outdated, but it has anecdotes and advice from students that I thing are still relevant and useful. The ebook was free through the library so I gave it a read.
  • A Guide to Academia by Prosanta Chakrabarty
    This one covers the entirety of grad school and also has information for postdocs and people looking for their first job. It’s a pretty solid overview. I think it’s was important to read ahead to learn about life after grad school and what to expect for the job market in academia. Also free through the library at Brown.

Of course, this is not an exhaustive list! If you have any suggestions on other books, or books that compare academia to industry, leave me a comment below.

Brown Club of Boston Biotech Conference

I just returned from an excellent conference sponsored by the Brown Club of Boston. The conference was designed to facilitate networking between Brown alumni, current students and leaders in all aspects of the biotechnology field. There was a panel of three interesting speakers, each of whom talked about their unique experience in the biotech industry.

  •  Angus McQuilken, VP of Communications and Marketing at the Massachusetts Life Sciences Center.

Angus spoke about the biotech boom that’s been happening in Massachusetts recently. A major reason for this is support from the state government – the Massachusetts Life Sciences Center was tasked with giving out $1 billion in funding to companies and individuals over a ten year period. Some of that money goes toward funding the internship challenge, a program that subsidizes internships for Mass residents and students working at biotech companies.

  • Mitch Sanders, Ph.D, founder and CEO of ECI Biotech

Mitch talked about his experience in biotech after his postdoc at MIT. His company is developing sensors that change color in the presence of certain bacteria and viruses – the tech is being applied to band-aids, prosthetics and food and will hopfully be on the market within the next couple of years. He also spoke about the ups and downs his company had been through in the past years and the importance of being able to adapt in the industry.

  • Elaine Crowley, founder and president of the Crowley Group.

The Crowley Group is a consulting firm that provides “insightful executive coaching” to companies and individuals. Although not limited to biotech, Eliane had some good lessons for the audience of students: finding employment that matches your culture is just as (if not more) important than the pay, prestige or benefits.

There was a Q&A session after the panelists spoke. I asked the three of them about the pros and cons of getting a Ph.D before working in the biotech industry, and the answers I recieved surprised me. More on that in a later post!

Many thanks to the members of the Brown Club of Boston who organized this event, especially Paula Freeman. who blogs about etiquette and lessons young people should learn over at jobetiquettebypaula.wordpress.com.